At&t Vs Page Plus Which Is Better For Teenagers - Complete Guide
When parents search "AT&T vs Page Plus — which is better for teenagers," they're really asking a deeper question: how do I get reliable coverage, safe features, and a fair price for my kid's first phone plan? Both AT&T and Page Plus have their appeal, but after running them through our 11-point eval
| Aspect | Detail |
|---|---|
| Our Pick | Tello or Visible |
| Best For | Teens & budget families |
| Price | From $8/month |
| Network | T-Mobile / Verizon |
| Our Score | 9.5/11 – 10/11 |
When parents search "AT&T vs Page Plus — which is better for teenagers," they're really asking a deeper question: how do I get reliable coverage, safe features, and a fair price for my kid's first phone plan? Both AT&T and Page Plus have their appeal, but after running them through our 11-point evaluation framework, neither lands at the top of our recommended list for teens. Better options exist.
Bottom Line: AT&T's postpaid plans are expensive and overkill for most teenagers, while Page Plus (a Verizon MVNO) offers solid coverage at a lower price — but it still falls short of MVNOs like Tello ($8–$25/mo on T-Mobile) or Visible ($25/mo on Verizon) that deliver more value, no contracts, and better parental peace of mind.
AT&T vs Page Plus: The Core Differences
Before we dive deep, it helps to understand what these two carriers actually are. AT&T is one of the "Big Three" postpaid carriers in the United States, operating its own nationwide network. Page Plus is a prepaid MVNO (Mobile Virtual Network Operator) that runs on Verizon's network — meaning it uses Verizon's towers without the Verizon price tag.
For parents shopping for a teenager's plan, this distinction matters a lot. Postpaid carriers like AT&T require credit checks, often lock you into contracts or device payment plans, and typically charge $40–$75+ per line. Prepaid MVNOs like Page Plus operate month-to-month with no credit checks, no contracts, and significantly lower costs — which is almost always the better fit for a teen's first phone plan.
What AT&T Offers Teens
AT&T's main draw is brand familiarity and a strong nationwide network. Their prepaid plans start around $25/month, while postpaid family plans can bundle a teen's line for roughly $35–$45/month when added to a multi-line account. AT&T also offers some parental controls through their ActiveArmor security app.
However, AT&T has had multiple documented data breaches in recent years — a significant concern if you're putting a minor on their service. Their 2024 breach exposed call and text records for nearly all wireless customers. For families prioritizing digital safety, that history is hard to overlook.
What Page Plus Offers Teens
Page Plus Cellular is a Verizon-based MVNO that's been around since 1993, making it one of the older prepaid brands in the US. Their plans start around $12/month for basic talk and text, going up to around $55/month for an unlimited plan. Because they run on Verizon's network, coverage is genuinely excellent — Verizon consistently ranks #1 or #2 in national coverage maps.
Page Plus is a solid budget option, but the user experience feels dated. Their website and app aren't as polished as newer MVNOs, customer service reviews are mixed, and they don't score particularly high on modern features like eSIM support or family account management tools.
Why Neither AT&T Nor Page Plus Is Our Top Pick for Teens
Running both carriers through our 11-point scoring system tells a clear story. AT&T (postpaid) isn't designed for teen budgets, and Page Plus, while functional, doesn't match the value or experience of newer MVNOs. Here's how the competitive landscape actually looks:
| Carrier | Network | Starting Price | Our Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Visible | Verizon | $25/mo (taxes included) | 10/11 |
| Tello | T-Mobile | $8/mo | 9.5/11 |
| US Mobile | All 3 networks | Custom plans | 9.5/11 |
| Metro by T-Mobile | T-Mobile | ~$25/mo | 6.5/11 |
| Boost Mobile | AT&T | ~$25/mo | 6/11 |
| Cricket Wireless | AT&T | ~$25/mo | 6/11 |
| AT&T (postpaid) | AT&T | $40+/mo | Not ranked |
| Page Plus | Verizon | $12/mo | Not ranked |
Best Prepaid Options for Teenagers in 2025
Tello: Best for Flexible, Low-Cost Teen Plans
Tello earns a 9.5/11 in our rankings and is arguably the best-kept secret in prepaid wireless for budget-conscious families. Plans start at just $8/month for basic talk and text, and you can build a custom plan that fits exactly what your teenager needs — whether that's 2GB of data or unlimited everything.
What makes Tello especially appealing for teens is the unlimited hotspot included on data plans, which is genuinely rare at this price point. A teenager can tether their laptop for homework without burning through a separate data allotment. Monthly prices for a practical teen plan typically land between $10–$25, making it one of the most affordable options on the market.
Tello runs on T-Mobile's network, which offers strong 5G coverage in urban and suburban areas. T-Mobile's network has improved dramatically in recent years and now rivals Verizon in most metropolitan regions. Tello has also maintained a clean data breach record — no documented incidents — which is reassuring for parents.
You can explore how Tello stacks up in more detail in our Tello vs other budget carriers comparison.
Visible: Best Single-Line Plan for Older Teens
Visible scores a perfect 10/11 in our rankings, and it's the only carrier to earn that distinction. At $25/month with taxes and fees already included, it offers unlimited talk, text, and data on Verizon's network — the same network Page Plus uses — but with a dramatically better user experience and app.
For a high schooler or college-bound teenager who needs reliable unlimited data and doesn't want to think about overages, Visible is the cleanest solution available. There are no contracts, no credit checks, and the signup process is entirely online and takes minutes. The flat $25 price means your teen's bill is predictable every single month.
Visible also has no documented data breaches, which puts it ahead of AT&T's troubled security history. The one trade-off is that Visible is best for single lines — their family pricing structure is less intuitive than carriers like Tello or US Mobile if you're managing multiple kids.
US Mobile: Best for Families With Multiple Teens
If you have more than one teenager to cover, US Mobile earns a 9.5/11 and offers something unique: access to all three major networks (Verizon, T-Mobile, and AT&T), plus the ability to build completely custom plans. You can mix and match data amounts across different lines depending on each kid's usage habits.
US Mobile's family plan pricing becomes increasingly competitive as you add lines. They also support eSIM, making it easy to activate service without waiting for a physical SIM card to arrive in the mail. For tech-savvy families who want flexibility and value, US Mobile is hard to beat.
Check out our full breakdown of US Mobile's multi-network approach and plan options to see if it's the right fit for your household.
Key Factors to Consider When Choosing a Teen's Phone Plan
Reasons to Choose an MVNO Over AT&T
- Significantly lower monthly cost ($8–$25 vs $40+)
- No contracts or credit checks required
- Month-to-month flexibility if needs change
- Cleaner data breach track records
- Often include unlimited hotspot
Potential Drawbacks of MVNOs for Teens
- Deprioritized data during network congestion
- Customer service may be online-only
- Some lack physical retail locations
- Parental control apps vary by carrier
- Device compatibility should be verified
Coverage: Does It Matter Which Network You Pick?
For teenagers, network coverage is usually about where they spend most of their time — school, home, and their friends' neighborhoods. Verizon's network (used by Visible, US Mobile, and Page Plus) has the broadest rural coverage in the US. T-Mobile's network (used by Tello) leads in 5G speed and urban density.
If your teen lives in a rural area, Verizon-based plans like Visible give the edge. If they're in a city or suburb, T-Mobile's network through Tello is likely just as good — and cheaper.
Data Limits and Hotspot Access
Most teenagers use between 3–10GB of data per month on cellular, with the rest happening over Wi-Fi at home or school. That said, unlimited plans have become affordable enough that they're often the smarter choice — no worrying about overages, no awkward conversations when your kid streams one too many YouTube videos.
Hotspot access is worth checking carefully. Tello includes unlimited hotspot on their plans, which is a standout feature. Visible includes hotspot but speeds are capped at 5Mbps on the base plan. Page Plus limits hotspot on most plans.
Parental Controls and Account Management
Neither AT&T nor Page Plus has standout parental control features built into the plan itself. Most families supplement their carrier with third-party apps like Google Family Link, Circle, or Bark regardless of which carrier they choose.
From a pure account-management perspective, Visible and Tello both have clean mobile apps and web portals that make it easy for a parent to monitor a plan, adjust data, or pause service if needed.
Why Trust Our Analysis? We evaluate carriers on 11 data-driven criteria including security features (2FA, SIM PIN protection), data breach history, pricing transparency, network reliability, and real user experience. Our rankings are based on verifiable facts, not paid placements. AT&T's documented 2024 data breach and Page Plus's limited modern feature set both factored into our assessments.
AT&T vs Page Plus: Direct Comparison for Teen Use
| Feature | AT&T (Prepaid) | Page Plus | Tello | Visible |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Starting Price | ~$25/mo | ~$12/mo | $8/mo | $25/mo |
| Network | AT&T | Verizon | T-Mobile | Verizon |
| Unlimited Plan | ~$50/mo | ~$55/mo | $25/mo | $25/mo |
| Hotspot Included | Yes (limited) | Limited | Unlimited | Yes (5Mbps) |
| eSIM Support | Yes | Limited | Yes | Yes |
| Data Breach History | Yes (2024) | None documented | None documented | None documented |
| Our Score | Not ranked | Not ranked | 9.5/11 | 10/11 |
| Contract Required | No | No | No | No |
Best Phone to Pair With This Plan
If you need an unlocked phone that works perfectly for a teenager on any of our recommended carriers, we recommend the Google Pixel 9a. It's our top budget phone pick for 2025:
- Works with all US carriers (Verizon, T-Mobile, AT&T networks)
- Supports eSIM + physical SIM for easy switching between plans
- 7 years of software updates — grows with your teen
- Excellent camera and battery life for the price
- Around $499 unlocked
The Bottom Line
When comparing AT&T vs Page Plus for teenagers, Page Plus edges out AT&T on price — but neither is truly the best option for teen plans in 2025. Tello (9.5/11) is our top pick for cost-conscious families, starting at just $8/month on T-Mobile's network with unlimited hotspot and no data breach history. Visible (10/11) is the best choice for a single unlimited line on Verizon's network at a flat $25/month including taxes. US Mobile (9.5/11) is ideal if you're managing plans for multiple kids across different network needs.
If you want to find the perfect plan match for your teenager's specific data habits and location, try our prepaid plan finder tool — it takes less than two minutes and narrows down the best options based on your zip code and usage.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is Page Plus a good phone plan for teenagers?
Page Plus is a decent budget option that runs on Verizon's reliable network, making it a reasonable choice if Verizon coverage is a priority in your area. However, newer MVNOs like Tello and Visible offer better pricing, cleaner apps, and stronger overall value for teens in 2025. Page Plus's interface and features feel dated compared to the competition.
Q: Can a teenager get an AT&T plan without a parent?
AT&T's postpaid plans require a credit check, so a teenager under 18 would typically need a parent or guardian to be the account holder. AT&T's prepaid plans don't require a credit check, but you'd still want an adult involved for payment methods and account management. For a simpler setup, prepaid MVNOs like Tello or Visible are entirely online and much easier to manage.
Q: How much data does a typical teenager use per month?
Most teenagers use between 3–10GB of mobile data per month when connected to Wi-Fi at home and school for most of their streaming. Heavy social media users or teens who stream video on cellular frequently can exceed 15GB. If you're unsure, starting with an unlimited plan from Visible or Tello at $25/month eliminates any overage concerns entirely.
Q: What's the cheapest phone plan for a teenager in 2025?
Tello offers plans starting at just $8/month for basic talk and text on T-Mobile's network, making it the most affordable option we recommend. For unlimited data, both Tello and Visible offer plans at $25/month — which is significantly cheaper than comparable plans from AT&T ($50+) or Page Plus ($55 for unlimited).
Q: Does Page Plus have parental controls?
Page Plus does not have built-in parental control features as part of their plans. Most families using Page Plus rely on third-party apps like Google Family Link, Bark, or Circle for monitoring and screen time management. This is true of most prepaid carriers — Tello and Visible also rely on third-party tools for parental controls rather than built-in features.
Affiliate Disclosure: Some links in this article are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not influence our rankings or recommendations, which are based on independent research and our 11-point evaluation criteria.
Related Articles
Is Verizon Actually Worth It If Under $100 - Complete Guide
If you're paying over $100 a month for Verizon service, you're almost certainly overpaying — and the question of whether Verizon is actually worth it under $100 has a surprisingly simple answer: yes, but not through Verizon directly. The best way to get Verizon-quality coverage without the postpaid
Cheapest Phone Plan For Light User With eSIM - Complete Guide
If you're a light phone user hunting for the cheapest phone plan with eSIM support, you're in the right place. The good news is that affordable prepaid carriers have caught up with modern smartphone technology — you no longer have to pay a premium just to activate a plan digitally.
Best MVNO / Prepaid Phone Plans Under $50 For Multiple Lines - Complete Guide
Finding a great family phone plan doesn't have to mean paying $200+ a month to the big carriers. The best prepaid phone plans under $50 for multiple lines can save a family of four anywhere from $1,000 to $2,000 per year — without sacrificing reliable coverage. In this guide, we rank the top MVNOs
Ready to switch carriers?
Find the perfect plan for your needs in minutes.
Recommended
Verizon network at half the price. Taxes included, no surprises.
- ✓ Verizon's best coverage
- ✓ Taxes & fees included
- ✓ No data breaches
Build your own plan. Unlimited hotspot included. Taxes included.
- ✓ Plans from $8/mo
- ✓ Unlimited hotspot
- ✓ No contracts ever
Best unlocked phone for MVNOs. Works with Visible, Tello, and all carriers.
- ✓ Unlocked for any carrier
- ✓ 7 years of updates
- ✓ eSIM + physical SIM