Consumer Cellular vs Straight Talk

Head-to-head comparison based on our 11-point scoring methodology. Updated February 2026.

AT&T

Consumer Cellular

0.0/11

0.0/11 — Poor

Winner

Multi-Network

Straight Talk

0.0/11

0.0/11 — Poor

Quick Verdict

Consumer Cellular wins with a score of 0.0/11. Consumer Cellular wins 0 of 11 scoring criteria while Straight Talk wins 0.

Read Consumer Cellular Review →Read Straight Talk Review →

11-Point Scoring Comparison

Criteria	Consumer Cellular	Straight Talk
💰Price $25 or under	No	No
📶35GB+ premium data	No	No
📊High data cap	No	No
📱Unlimited talk & text	No	No
🔧Build-a-plan options	No	No
🔐SIM PIN protection	No	No
🛡️2FA security	No	No
📡Good coverage	No	No
✅No data breaches	No	No
♾️True unlimited data	No	No
💬Good customer service	No	No
Total Score	0.0/11	0.0/11

Network & Security

Feature	Consumer Cellular	Straight Talk
Network	AT&T	Multi-Network
2FA Available	No	No
SIM PIN	No	No
Data Breaches	Yes	Yes

Our Recommendation

Between these two, Consumer Cellular scores higher. However, both carriers score below our top picks. For the best value in prepaid wireless, consider:

Visible — 10.0/11

Unlimited Verizon, $25/mo, taxes included

Tello — 9.5/11

Build-a-plan on T-Mobile, from $10/mo

Related Comparisons

Consumer Cellular vs Visible →Straight Talk vs Visible →Consumer Cellular vs Tello →Straight Talk vs Tello →Consumer Cellular vs US Mobile →Straight Talk vs US Mobile →Consumer Cellular vs Twigby →Straight Talk vs Twigby →

Full Consumer Cellular Review →Full Straight Talk Review →

This comparison is based on our independent 11-point scoring methodology. Scores are calculated from objective criteria including price, data, security, and customer service. Learn about our methodology.